Effectiveness of Collars and Hooked-Collars in Mitigating Scour around Different Abutment Shapes

oleh: Zaka Ullah Khan, Afzal Ahmed, Manousos Valyrakis, Ghufran Ahmed Pasha, Rashid Farooq, Nadir Murtaza, Diyar Khan

Format: Article
Diterbitkan: MDPI AG 2024-09-01

Deskripsi

Abutment scour is a major cause of bridge failures worldwide, leading to disruptions, economic losses, and loss of life. The present experimental study examines countermeasures against abutment scour using hooked-collar protections on vertical-wall and wing-wall abutments (at 45° and 60°) under different flow conditions. All 60 experiments were performed under sub-critical flow conditions by investigating scour around an abutment 20 cm long, 20 cm wide, and 25 cm tall. Two distinct values of the Froude number, 0.154 and 0.179, and a sediment particle diameter (<i>d</i><sub>50</sub>) of 0.88 mm were used throughout the experimental phase. The resulting equilibrium scour around the abutments was compared to those with collar and hooked-collar protections. It was determined that the maximum abutment scour depth reduction was 83.89% when hooked collars were placed on vertical wall abutments beneath the bed surface level, and for wing-wall abutments at 45° and 60°, it was 74.2% and 73.5%, respectively, at the bed surface level. Regression analysis was conducted to assess the non-dimensional scour depth <i>(D<sub>s</sub>/Y<sub>f</sub>)</i> and scour reduction (<i>R<sub>Ds</sub>/Y<sub>f</sub></i>), with a high enough coefficient of determination (<i>R</i><sup>2</sup> values of 0.96 and 0.93, respectively), indicating high confidence in the analysis. The sensitivity analysis findings demonstrate that the width of the collar (<i>W<sub>c</sub></i>) and <i>L<sub>a</sub></i> are the most influencing factors affecting <i>D<sub>s</sub>/Y<sub>f</sub></i> and <i>RD<sub>s</sub>/Y<sub>f</sub>.</i>